Rogan Josh Recipe (Lamb Rogan Josh)
Updated: November 25, 2024, By Swasthi
Rogan Josh, a classic comfort food from the Kashmiri Cuisine is a slow cooked dish made with lamb, spices, herbs and yogurt. You will seriously be hooked to this beautiful authentic Kashmiri Rogan Josh and will turn back to it, time & again for a spectacular feast.
Serve it with plain steamed rice, Chapati, Tandoori Roti, Butter naan, Sheermal, plain basmati rice or Turmeric rice. This recipe will give you soft, tender and juicy lamb with fall-off-the-bone tender meat in an extremely delicious sauce.
About Rogan Josh
Absolutely phenomenal in taste and texture, Rogan josh, the deep red spicy meat curry, is the signature dish of Kashmir and is an integral part of the lavish Kashmiri food spread known as “Wazwaan”. In fact, this multi-course meal is one which you should be tasting at least once in your life since the dishes are so lip-smacking and delicious.
There are various interpretations of the name which I learnt. Rogan, pronounced as “roughan” means “oil or ghee” in Persian. While in Urdu, it may mean “brown or red”. On the other hand, “Josh” (jus) refers “to braise” or “stew”. Other meaning may be the intense heat. So Rogan josh may mean one that is “stewed or braised in ghee”.
Table of contents
Like Nihari and Hyderabadi Marag, traditionally Rogan josh is prepared by slow-cooking meat over a low heat for several hours. In the recent times, a pressure cooker is used to cook the meat quickly.
But nothing can beat the slow cooked rogan josh. When the meat is simmered, it lends the dish a deep and substantial flavor that is also unique. Slow cooking seeps the marrow from the bones into the gravy making it thicker and delicious.
The thickness you taste and see in an authentic Rogan Josh comes from the bone marrow, red chili paste, fennel powder, ginger powder and yogurt but not from onions, garlic and tomatoes. Some recipes do not even use yogurt and instead use pran (wild shallot paste).
More Similar Recipes
Lamb Karahi
Goat Curry
Lamb Curry
Lamb Vindaloo
Mutton/goat Korma
Mutton Curry
Mutton Biryani
Photo Guide
Traditional Vs Modernized version
Rogan josh gets its characteristic red color from the Kashmiri Red chilies and again not from tomatoes. Also the usage of ratan jot, an herb from the borage family enhances the deep color. Alternately a lot of people also use Cockscomb flower known as maval locally, for the the red color.
You will also find many households and restaurants making this without both ratan jot or cockscomb flower since both these do not make much difference to the flavor of rogan josh. A lot of restaurants use food color but I suggest simply to leave out these ingredients if they are not available.
There are numerous versions of this popular dish on the internet. Some use tomatoes for more volume, but this alters the original authentic taste considerably. Similarly, fresh ginger and garlic are not used in the original one. Instead, asafetida (Hing) is added to get the flavor base of onion and garlic.
The usage of onions, tomatoes, ginger and garlic makes it a regular Mutton curry and not ROGAN JOSH.
Two methods of Cooking
Rogan josh is prepared in 2 methods – Hindu Pandit method and the Kashmiri Muslim method. As such a lot of Kashmiri recipes vary depending on the community and region.
In the Hindu Pandit method, yogurt is used and involves searing and braising the meat, which isn’t included in the other method. Onion, fresh ginger, and garlic are avoided. Likewise, Ghee is used in this method.
In the Muslim version, a unique flavor enhancer known as pran or praan is used. It is made by deep frying wild onion or shallots until golden. These are later ground in a mortar pestle along with the oil in which they are fried. The resulting paste is a light and super flavorful ingredient that takes the dish to a new level.
Apart from these 2, a lot of households and chefs have their own recipes to make the dish. Some people use mustard oil instead of ghee and some use garlic.
My Rogan Josh Recipe
My Recipe is super simple and uses pantry staples. You will be surprised at how delicious this turns out with minimal ingredients/ spices. Though easy to make, it is not a fast recipe and as you know slow cooking mutton is what makes this dish the “BEST”.
Whether you are making a weeknight family dinner or in need of something amazing that will satisfy a crowd, this is an excellent aromatic dish that tastes close to the authentic version. This incredibly delicious fare packs a serious flavor punch from the ground spices like ginger, fennel and red chili.
This dish is made with mutton – goat or lamb. You may use your favorite meat including chicken but you won’t require so much liquid and red chilli powder.
Traditionally this dish is made with Kashmiri chili paste which adds volume and red color to the dish without making it too hot and pungent. For convenience I have used Kashmiri red chili powder. All the ingredients used in this recipe will be available easily in an Indian grocery stores.
Since we do not eat very spicy and hot foods I have used only 1 tablespoon red chilli powder. I have used ratan jot as it is easily available. Feel free to skip it. Here is how to use it.
Photo Guide
How to use Ratan Jot
Ratan Jot or Alkanet root – The root of this plant was extensively used in traditional Indian cooking for its color. What’s more, it even imparts a mild flavor. This ingredient is optional and you may omit it. It is available online easily and here is how to use it if you are able to source it.
Heat two tablespoons of ghee or oil in a saucepan along with a few pieces of the ratan jot. Keep stirring for 1 to 2 mins until ratan jot is soaked up in ghee. I had to add more ghee and more herb. Please use more as required.
Once the ghee becomes red, reduce the heat and let it simmer for 2 to 3 mins. Turn off the heat and allow the herb to steep until you need. Keep the pan in a slightly hot place so the ghee does not solidify. Remove the ratan jot or strain it through a filter and add it at the end, during the last 2 to 3 mins of cooking.
You can also make a large batch of this and store it in a wide jar/container for easy scooping. It keeps good for about an year in the refrigerator.
Dried Cockscomb Flower – Instead of Ratan Jot, you can use dried cockscomb flower also. Soak them in warm water for 20 minutes. Strain and use it. It gives the dish a distinctive taste (very mild) and color to the dish.
Related Recipes
Recipe Card
Rogan Josh Recipe (Lamb Rogan Josh)
For best results follow the step-by-step photos above the recipe card
Ingredients (US cup = 240ml )
- 1.1 lbs. (500 grams) bone-in mutton (tender lamb, like leg of lamb or shoulder, cut to 2 inch pieces)
- 2 to 3 tablespoons ghee or mustard oil (refer notes)
- ¼ teaspoon asafoetida (hing, skip if you don't have)
- ½ cup curd (yogurt at room temperature, preferably fresh and not sour)
- ¾ teaspoon salt (adjust to taste)
- 1 to 1½ tablespoon Kashmiri red chili powder (or 2 tbsps. Kashmiri red chili paste)
- 1 cup hot water (or mutton stock, + more as required, up to 5 cups depending on the meat)
- 1¼ cup sliced shallots or yellow onion (optional, refer notes)
Spices (refer notes)
- 1 bay leaf (skip if you don't have)
- 3 to 4 cloves (or ¼ teaspoon ground cloves)
- 1 inch cinnamon (or ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon)
- 3 green cardamoms (or ⅓ teaspoon ground cardamoms)
- 1 black cardamom (skip if you don't have)
- 2 teaspoon fennel seeds powder
- 1 teaspoon dried ginger powder (or substitute 1 teaspoon ginger paste)
- 1 teaspoon garam masala (optional)
Instructions
How to Make Rogan Josh
- This step is optional. But it helps to thicken the rogan josh. Heat 1.5 tablespoons oil in a pan and saute shallots/onions on a medium heat until golden, about to caramelize but not burnt. Cool them and blend with 2 to 3 tablespoons of yogurt to a smooth paste. Keep this aside.
- Heat oil or ghee in a heavy bottom pot and add bay leaf, green cardamoms, cinnamon, cloves and black cardamoms. (If you opt for the ground spices, add them later.)
- When the spices begin to sizzle in oil, add mutton and sear it for 1 to 2 minute on a high heat.
- Reduce the heat to medium and fry for another 4 to 5 minutes until the meat is slightly brown.
- While you fry the meat, add yogurt to a mixing bowl. Also add ground spices – red chilli powder, fennel powder, dried ginger powder and salt.
- Whisk all of them well. If your yogurt is too thick (like Greek yogurt), add 3 to 4 tablespoons of water or stock and whisk it well until smooth.
- Once the meat is light brown in color, add hing to the oil. Take the pot off the stove and slowly stir in the spice and yogurt mixture.
- Mix well and place the pot back on the stove. Cook covered for 3 to 4 minutes on a medium heat.
- Pour 1 cup hot water or stock. Cook covered on a low heat until tender, adding more hot water if required.
- Stir rogan josh every 7 to 8 minutes. When it is done, the mutton pieces should be soft, tender and fall off the bone. (Optional – During the last 20 minutes of cooking add the blended onion paste and mix well.)
- The cook time depends on the kind of pot, source of heat and the intensity of heat. Do not forget to add more hot water (if required) as you cook. It takes me 2 hours for the mutton to get tender.
- The gravy in Rogan josh is neither too runny nor too thick but is slightly thick as the some of the bone marrow seeps into the liquids. This results can be achieved only by slow cooking the dish.
- Taste test and add more salt or garam masala if required. Turn off the heat and rest for few hours before serving. This helps to develop the flavors.
- Serve rogan josh with Tandoori Roti, Butter Naan, Basmati Rice, Paratha or Roti. It is best served with plain rice.
Notes
- If using mustard oil, first heat it until smoking hot. Reduce the heat and then begin to cook.
- My spice combination makes this recipe the best. However if you do not have whole spices, then use garam masala plus fennel powder and fresh ginger paste.
- If using fresh ginger paste, add it when the mutton is light brown. Slide the mutton to a side and add the ginger paste to ghee/oil. Fry quickly until aromatic without burning.
- This recipe has been updated to use onions/shallots (for a thicker gravy) and garam masala. These are not used in the traditional rogan josh.
- To use pran, skip using yogurt and use 4 to 5 tbsps of pran paste along with the ground spices. After searing the mutton, pour hot water or stock and cook until 50% done (half cooked). Then add all the ground spices and the pran paste.
- If using store bought bottled pran, make sure it is fresh and does not smell rancid. Pran stored in glass containers and made with ghee keeps good for longer.
NUTRITION INFO (estimation only)
© Swasthi’s Recipes
About Swasthi
I’m Swasthi Shreekanth, the recipe developer, food photographer & food writer behind Swasthi’s Recipes. My aim is to help you cook great Indian food with my time-tested recipes. After 2 decades of experience in practical Indian cooking I started this blog to help people cook better & more often at home. Whether you are a novice or an experienced cook I am sure Swasthi’s Recipes will assist you to enhance your cooking skills. More about me
Follow Swasthi’s Recipes
Comments
Damn good
Thank you!
Wonderful recipe..tried and came out best
Thanks for sharing back!
Hi Swasthi
We had this last night and must say it was very flavourful.
Used all the ingredients except the cockcomb. Also used the shallot and yogurt mix.
Had a problem getting the lamb to get to the point of falling off the bone, took well over 8 hours and it was extremely fatty, but that not the fault of the recipe.
Hi Renee,
Thank you for sharing back. It should have tasted extremely good due to the long cooking hours. But I am just wondering if you cooked the whole lamb shoulder (uncut) which could be the reason. I will update my recipe to be clear on that.
You are right, I did indeed cook the entire shoulder including the ribs, my husband cut it up into three or four pieces. I’ve cooked local fresh lamb for years and have never seen one with so
much fat. We started cooking (about 4 hours) it on Thursday, knowing it would need to continue cooking the next day.
The next day removed about a cup of fat before continuing to cook it all afternoon, by then it was still really tough, so we stick it back in the fridge. The the third time was the charm, removed at least a cup of congealed fat and cooked it again. It was merely on your mouth tender and flavour was outstanding. Was not sure when to add the ratan not, so I added it at the same time as the prat. Was also not sure if I should remove the root or not, so I played it safe and removed it.
Your recipes are fabulous, will keep trying a new one each week.
Renee, a easier way to cook tougher lamb is to marinate with raw papaya paste for 2 hours (no longer). Remove the paste as much as possible and begin to cook. (Usually people rinse it off before proceeding).You should add the ratan jot infused ghee during the last 2 to 3 mins of cooking. It should be removed or strained to discard the ratan, before adding. I will edit to update. Thank you for sharing back! Hope you enjoy more dishes.
Thanks for all the extra information, it sure helps a lot. Will try this again soon with the changes you suggested.
Hi
Sounds like another great recipe, can’t wait to try it. So far I’ve made you Chana masala which was delish and you chicken tikka masala which was truly outstanding.
Should I be buying lamb shoulder or a leg of lamb for this dish?
Hi Renee,
Thank you! Use lamb shoulder but if you can’t get you may use leg of lamb. Hope you enjoy
Hi swasthi, thanks so much for your help!
Yikes! My hubby came home today with 2 kilos of lamb shoulder, so I have a question. Your recipe says to add one cup of water when the recipe is for 3 , the same amount of water when the recipe is increased to ten servings. I’m guessing I’ll need at least three cups of water, do you agree or have a suggestion.
I bought some ratan jot today, read your how to, but I’m not sure when to add it. I have every other ingredient to make it authentic as possible, other than the mustard oil, unfortunately what I bought was for external use only.
Can’t wait to try this!
Hi Renee,
Add hot water in batches when you convert a recipe from 1x to 2x or 3x, starting with the amount called for 1x. Add the ratan jot at the end, 5 mins before turning off the heat. You can cook in ghee. Hope you all enjoy the dish
I tried this in my work kitchen. Amazing flavour and great taste. All co-workers loved it.
Thank you Loyed. So glad to read that
Amazing how little masala it has, so easy to make, and soo yum. It was even tastier after a few hours, so wd.recommend making it in advance- say morning, if it’s for dinner. I made it without pran etc as I didn’t have that, but otherwise exactly as per the recipe. 1 tsp byadgi chilli pwd was just right for us. Yum! Thank you.
Go glad you like it Anjali. Yes I agree, resting enhances the flavor. We usually eat the next day for lunch because the meat is not marinated, resting makes it the best. Thanks for sharing back how it went for you.
Good morning Swasthi: I am having a tough time finding any “bone in” lamb to use for your wonderful Rogan Josh. How much would using boneless lamb stew meat alter the delicious taste? Carol
Good Morning Carol,
Yes you may use stew meat and for the liquid, use stock or bone broth (start with lesser liquid). I think it should be alright. Hope you get to try!
This might just be my favourite recipe of all time! The marrow makes this utterly delightful. Next time I’ll trim the fat on the meat to trim the calories. It’s outrageously delicious and easy to make – took 3 hours on my stove but I have no regrets. I’m still deciding if this is as good or better than my local restaurant!
Thank you so much Annabelle for sharing back! Happy to read that!
When to use the Hing? If I am using ratan jot do i need to use kashmiri mirch powder?
Hi,
After you saute the meat, stir in the hing. It is mentioned in the recipe card. Kashmiri mirch is for mild heat and ratan jot is for color.
Excellent.
Thank you
This rogan josh turned out spectacular and my husband loved it. The only change was to leave out the garam masala and double the fennel and ground ginger. I think this is the first recipe I found on your blog without step by step photos. But no worries turned out delicious. Thank you and keep up the great work.
Glad you like it Saumya. Yes I haven’t shared the pictures yet. I will be doing it soon. Thanks for trying.
In rogan josh receipe you have not mentioned when to use ratan josh and in what quantity.
Add it towards the end, during the last 3 to 4 mins of cooking. Temper it in 2 to 3 tbsps ghee. Add as much as you want until your rogan josh looks bright red. Store the left over in the fridge and reheat for next time.
I’ve cooked this dish and it turned out quite well. I slow cooked it and the meat(lamb shoulder) became very tender. But the sauce got very, and I mean really thin. I followed the recipe and quantities, using mustard oil, greek yoghurt, Anaheim chili powder and sweet paprika 2:1 and 240ml of hot water. I was afraid the yoghurt would curdle, which didn’t happen, though. I expected the sauce to thicken up a bit, but it got even thinner during the process. The flavours were fine. What should I do different next time?
Hi Nat,
Authentic Rogan josh sauce is not thick like other curries and it basically has more of the bone marrow flavor & is runny as seen in the pictures. However if you want it thicker, you may saute 1.25 cups sliced onions (yellow onion or shallots) until golden, make a fine paste with little yogurt and add it during the last 20 minutes of cooking.
thanks.
This is a. Very nice and tasty very rich in flavour ??
I had been looking for an authentic Indian rogan josh and this recipe ends my search! It turned out amazing so much different and easier than any other rogan josh recipes out there on the internet. Pinned it so I don’t loose the link. Thanks for sharing your Indian culture.
Best rogan josh! I added a teaspoon of your garam masala before finishing. It was very delicious. Next time I’m going to double the recipe. Keep up the good work.
Thanks for sharing back Julie. Yes you can add garam masala. Happy to know you like it.
ThanK you for the authentic rogan josh recipe. It was very delicious and have made it thrice in tbe last few months. It is hard for people to understand Indian food is just not tons of tomatoes and spices. While searching for a real Rogan Josh recipe I found many recipes online and none of them were even real. This recipe is a keeper!
Shaheen so true. Every Indian food does not require tomatoes and plenty of spices. Thanks for trying and sharing back.
Was wondering if after I sweat and brown the lamb with the whole spices if I should crush the cardamom seeds. To help add more flavor. I’m not usually the cook in the house but I can follow directions. I didn’t know how hot or how long to cook the whole spices. I thought the aroma would fill my whole house, but it wasn’t quite that strong as I thought it would be. Overall it really was a good dish. I’m usually a vindaloo guy always!! But family is not…
Hi Barney,
You don’t need to cook the whole spices. You will just wait for them to sizzle and then add the lamb. Traditional Rogan josh has more natural meat flavors and won’t really have any dominating spice flavors. However you are free to add more ginger, fennel and even ground cardamom. I suggest you play around with the ground spices and may be you can also try with a strong meat masala or garam masala if that’s what you are looking for. Thank you for trying and sharing how it turned for you.
This was an excellent recipe. I’ve had rogan josh at many Indian restaurants, and was never really impressed by it, but this recipe is easy to make, simple and absolutely delicious.
Thank you Marga for trying and sharing back.
HI Swasthi,
great recipe!
its the best rogan josh I have ever had.
I cant find hing, so Im doing a sub of garlic, and onion powder.
should i add to the yogurt mix with the other dry spices?
Hi Beth,
Thank you! Yes add them to the yogurt.
Thank you. This turned out wonderful!
Glad you like it Kavya